Think You’re Getting a Deal on Car Insurance? You’re Probably Not

by Linda Foster
Jul 2, 2025
senior man taking care of his car

If you're over 60, chances are your car insurance premium hasn't kept up with your actual risk level, and that's costing you. Insurers often use outdated data or one-size-fits-all pricing that doesn’t account for your current driving habits or financial goals. But with the right tools and a few strategic moves, seniors are taking back control and saving big.

Here’s how to reassess your coverage and uncover the savings most drivers never realize they’re missing.

1. Add Extra Protection Without the Extra Price

Most car insurance plans cover accidents but not mechanical breakdowns. That means if your transmission or air conditioning fails, you pay out of pocket. A vehicle service contract from Endurance Auto helps cover those costs. Plans include roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and repairs at your preferred mechanic or dealership. Coverage is backed by an AM Best “A-” rated insurer and comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee. You can even get $300 off just for signing up.

2. Refinance Your Auto Loan Like a Pro

Still paying off your car? You might be stuck with a high interest rate from years ago. National Auto Loan Network helps you refinance your auto loan at today’s lower rates, potentially saving you up to $100 per month. With a quick online application and no in-person visits required, you can complete the process entirely online and start saving.

3. Don’t Fall for Big Brand Bias

Bigger names don’t always mean better value. Many smaller or regional insurers offer the same coverage at much lower premiums. Coverage is a free tool that pulls real-time rates from top-rated providers, giving you the power to compare quotes and customize coverage based on your needs, not just brand recognition.

Stretching every dollar? You’re not alone.

These senior-tested tips are helping retirees stretch $1,000 further than ever — without cutting out the things that matter most.

4. Bundle and Save Where It Counts

Bundling home and car protection is one of the easiest ways to simplify your bills and cut costs. American Home Shield offers comprehensive home warranty coverage that protects systems like HVAC, plumbing, and appliances. When paired with the right insurer, bundling may qualify you for significant discounts on your overall monthly expenses.

5. Compare Policies in Minutes (Seriously)

Car insurance rates change constantly, and sticking with one provider may mean you’re missing out on better deals. Insurify is a comparison platform that shows you live quotes from dozens of insurers. You can filter by coverage needs and budget, helping you choose smarter in less time, with no phone calls or pressure required.

Stop Letting Car Insurance Ride on Autopilot

Car insurance premiums aren’t fixed forever, and treating them that way can cost you. Seniors are finding real savings by reviewing coverage regularly, exploring new tools, and tapping into options beyond the usual big brands. Whether it's refinancing your loan or bundling smartly, there’s real money to be saved when you take control.


Related Posts
Get Wiser Every Day.
Signup now for the Wise Senior newsletter
to save money, and get the most out of retirement!

By clicking on 'Sign Up', you agree to our Terms and Conditions & Privacy Policy